Showing posts with label Scotland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scotland. Show all posts
16 August 2009
The Reformation in Scotland
Next year will be the 450th anniversary of the Protestant reformation in Scotland, a fact to which Kevin McKenna has drawn our attention here.
England and Scotland were under separate crowns in 1560 of course, with the Tudors south of the border and the Stuarts to the north. Scotland had been spared the long drama of England's Reformation -- the drama of Henry VIII's contentious break with Katherine of Aragorn, and as a consequence with the Church of Rome, or for that matter the shifting ecclesiastical politics of his subsequent marriages. Scotland had been spared, too, the brief reign of Edward, who encouraged Calvinist tendencies in the newly established Church, then the retrograde movement under bloody Mary, who sought to return to the Roman fold, while inventing a cocktail named for hersef.
No, in 1560 Elizabeth was new to the crown, and she would over time reverse her sister's reversal of her father's revolution, but give Protestantism a distinctive non-Genevan twist in the process. And it was in 1560 that the Scottish Parliament set up a "Committee of the Articles" that after three weeks of deliberation recommended the condemnation of the doctrines of transubstantiation, justification by works, indulgences, purgatory, and papal authority. The full Parliament agreed, on August 17th of that year -- 449 years ago tomorow.
McKenna, then, is getting a jump on the 450th celebration with his own essay, which starts out with his own (Catholic) childhood and youth, and rather oddly focuses not on any of ther issues the old Scottish Parliament found decisively offensive, but on the controversy over graven images. In his case, his tendency to venerate a particular image appears to have been mingled with Mariolatry as well.
I'll reproduce his touching first two paragraphs here, allowing you to follow the above link for the rest:
Our Lady of Maryhill was three feet tall with a beatific countenance, her head encircled by a halo of golden stars. Under her dainty feet, which were supported by a grey plinth, lay a crushed serpent. She had been with me from childhood and had seen action in various north Glasgow dwellings as well as the Protestant stronghold of Kilwinning in Ayrshire.
On those occasions when I returned home for the weekend, my student flatmate would ask politely if he could commandeer my room for the purposes of entertaining women. As he was an incorrigible atheist and thus knew no better, I readily assented to his fell requests. There was only one condition. That he gently place my madonna inside the top drawer of my dresser during his assignations. Thus she would be spared the regrettable scenes of prenuptial houghmagandy taking place before her.
Houghmagandy? the word is new to me, although its meaning in context is not mysterious.
England and Scotland were under separate crowns in 1560 of course, with the Tudors south of the border and the Stuarts to the north. Scotland had been spared the long drama of England's Reformation -- the drama of Henry VIII's contentious break with Katherine of Aragorn, and as a consequence with the Church of Rome, or for that matter the shifting ecclesiastical politics of his subsequent marriages. Scotland had been spared, too, the brief reign of Edward, who encouraged Calvinist tendencies in the newly established Church, then the retrograde movement under bloody Mary, who sought to return to the Roman fold, while inventing a cocktail named for hersef.
No, in 1560 Elizabeth was new to the crown, and she would over time reverse her sister's reversal of her father's revolution, but give Protestantism a distinctive non-Genevan twist in the process. And it was in 1560 that the Scottish Parliament set up a "Committee of the Articles" that after three weeks of deliberation recommended the condemnation of the doctrines of transubstantiation, justification by works, indulgences, purgatory, and papal authority. The full Parliament agreed, on August 17th of that year -- 449 years ago tomorow.
McKenna, then, is getting a jump on the 450th celebration with his own essay, which starts out with his own (Catholic) childhood and youth, and rather oddly focuses not on any of ther issues the old Scottish Parliament found decisively offensive, but on the controversy over graven images. In his case, his tendency to venerate a particular image appears to have been mingled with Mariolatry as well.
I'll reproduce his touching first two paragraphs here, allowing you to follow the above link for the rest:
Our Lady of Maryhill was three feet tall with a beatific countenance, her head encircled by a halo of golden stars. Under her dainty feet, which were supported by a grey plinth, lay a crushed serpent. She had been with me from childhood and had seen action in various north Glasgow dwellings as well as the Protestant stronghold of Kilwinning in Ayrshire.
On those occasions when I returned home for the weekend, my student flatmate would ask politely if he could commandeer my room for the purposes of entertaining women. As he was an incorrigible atheist and thus knew no better, I readily assented to his fell requests. There was only one condition. That he gently place my madonna inside the top drawer of my dresser during his assignations. Thus she would be spared the regrettable scenes of prenuptial houghmagandy taking place before her.
Houghmagandy? the word is new to me, although its meaning in context is not mysterious.
Labels:
God,
Mariolatry,
Papacy,
Protestantism,
Scotland
30 August 2007
Our Times
As promised, my guess at the ten most important world-historical events since 1993.
First, let's treat of the military/diplomatic matters.
1. January 1, 1994, the North American Free Trade Agreement goes into effect.
2. May 1998, the first "euro" coins are minted.
3. September 11, 2001, enough said.
4. February 1, 2002, a kidnapped Wall Street Journal Reporter, Daniel Pearl, is murdered by his kidnappers in Pakistan.
5. October 16, 2002, George W. Bush signs the Iraq War Resolution.
Next, let's discuss politics, in a narrow sense, in some of the leading powers of the day.
6. March 1996, the Republic of China (i.e. Taiwan) holds its first-ever direct election for President.
7. December 5, 1996, The chairman of the Federal Reserve in the U.S., Alan Greenspan, gives a speech warning that stock values in the US may have become inflated due to "irrational exuberance."
8. June 2007, In the U.K., Tony Blair steps down, and his Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gordon Brown, becomes both the new leader of the Labour Party and the new Prime Minister.
Finally, there are a couple other events that I can't bring myself to leave off any such list.
9. March 1995, Nick Leeson is arrested for his role in the collapse of one of the world's oldest banks, Barings. This became known as the "rogue trader" case.
10. February 1997, Scientists in Scotland announced that they've cloned a sheep, which they call Dolly.
First, let's treat of the military/diplomatic matters.
1. January 1, 1994, the North American Free Trade Agreement goes into effect.
2. May 1998, the first "euro" coins are minted.
3. September 11, 2001, enough said.
4. February 1, 2002, a kidnapped Wall Street Journal Reporter, Daniel Pearl, is murdered by his kidnappers in Pakistan.
5. October 16, 2002, George W. Bush signs the Iraq War Resolution.
Next, let's discuss politics, in a narrow sense, in some of the leading powers of the day.
6. March 1996, the Republic of China (i.e. Taiwan) holds its first-ever direct election for President.
7. December 5, 1996, The chairman of the Federal Reserve in the U.S., Alan Greenspan, gives a speech warning that stock values in the US may have become inflated due to "irrational exuberance."
8. June 2007, In the U.K., Tony Blair steps down, and his Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gordon Brown, becomes both the new leader of the Labour Party and the new Prime Minister.
Finally, there are a couple other events that I can't bring myself to leave off any such list.
9. March 1995, Nick Leeson is arrested for his role in the collapse of one of the world's oldest banks, Barings. This became known as the "rogue trader" case.
10. February 1997, Scientists in Scotland announced that they've cloned a sheep, which they call Dolly.
22 April 2007
Religion and News From Scotland
I'm human companion for a handsome sheltie named Angus, who's just turning two years old about now, so I've decided I have a vested interest in matters Scottish.
Let's recall a classic episode of The Simpsons, in which the stereotypical kilts-wearing Scotsman "Willie," the school groundskeeper, observes a brother and sister playing together with a surprising degree of amiability.
He tells the principal (and you'll have to imagine the burr here, I'm going to keep the spelling conventional), "It won't last. Brothers and sisters are natural enemies. Like Scots and the English. Or Scots and the Irish. Or Scots and the French. Or Scots and other Scots."
"Yes, you Scots sure are a contentious people."
"You've just made yourself an enemy for life, principal Skinner!"
(I dislike ethnic stereotype, BTW. But there do exist erudite Jews, argumentative Scots, uptight WASPs, and maybe even a Greek or two whose gifts require wary examination.)
This is Sunday, so let's speak of the Kirk. Within the post-Reformation tradition in Scotland, the tradition of John Knox, one finds of course, the established Church of Scotland, the Free Church of Scotland (which broke off in 1900), the United Free Church of Scotland (formed in 1929), the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland, the Associated Presbyterian Churches, and the Free Church of Scotland (Continuing).
The good news is that, contrary groundskeeper Willie's presumptions about his nation, they have been coming together of late. Last September the Church of Scotland signed a covenant with the United Free Church allowing for shared services and other common activities. Talks continue between the CS and the FCS toward similar ends, which have resulted in a joint statement "of mutual recognition and understanding and a mutual commitment to cooperate in the advancement of the kingdom of God."
All the ecumenical warmth generated by reading such a statement led me to go to the home page of the FCS, http://www.freechurch.org
where I found a fascinating statement of the difficulties that face its ministry.
http://www.freechurch.org/issues/2007/april07.htm
The minister is pulled in several directions by his congregants, I'm told.
"The traditionalists think we are there to maintain their traditions (not other people’s); the radicals think we are too traditional and want us to follow their new traditions; the liberals are theologically confused but for some reason like some aspects of the Church and want us cater for their particular tastes; the charismatics don’t understand why we don’t get it; the pietists are always bemoaning other people’s lack of spirituality (especially their ministers) and the legalists are always looking for the next war in the church to fight."
Divisiveness in religion isn't, then, a trick promoted by an elite to prevent the wonderful egalitarian unity that might break out otherwise. Divisiveness comes from the ranks and works its way up. Well ... that's one way to look at it.
A shot of whiskey, a round of "fetch" with Angus, and we'll leave the future in the hands of a higher power ("however we choose to conceive of it" as they say at AA).
Let's recall a classic episode of The Simpsons, in which the stereotypical kilts-wearing Scotsman "Willie," the school groundskeeper, observes a brother and sister playing together with a surprising degree of amiability.
He tells the principal (and you'll have to imagine the burr here, I'm going to keep the spelling conventional), "It won't last. Brothers and sisters are natural enemies. Like Scots and the English. Or Scots and the Irish. Or Scots and the French. Or Scots and other Scots."
"Yes, you Scots sure are a contentious people."
"You've just made yourself an enemy for life, principal Skinner!"
(I dislike ethnic stereotype, BTW. But there do exist erudite Jews, argumentative Scots, uptight WASPs, and maybe even a Greek or two whose gifts require wary examination.)
This is Sunday, so let's speak of the Kirk. Within the post-Reformation tradition in Scotland, the tradition of John Knox, one finds of course, the established Church of Scotland, the Free Church of Scotland (which broke off in 1900), the United Free Church of Scotland (formed in 1929), the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland, the Associated Presbyterian Churches, and the Free Church of Scotland (Continuing).
The good news is that, contrary groundskeeper Willie's presumptions about his nation, they have been coming together of late. Last September the Church of Scotland signed a covenant with the United Free Church allowing for shared services and other common activities. Talks continue between the CS and the FCS toward similar ends, which have resulted in a joint statement "of mutual recognition and understanding and a mutual commitment to cooperate in the advancement of the kingdom of God."
All the ecumenical warmth generated by reading such a statement led me to go to the home page of the FCS, http://www.freechurch.org
where I found a fascinating statement of the difficulties that face its ministry.
http://www.freechurch.org/issues/2007/april07.htm
The minister is pulled in several directions by his congregants, I'm told.
"The traditionalists think we are there to maintain their traditions (not other people’s); the radicals think we are too traditional and want us to follow their new traditions; the liberals are theologically confused but for some reason like some aspects of the Church and want us cater for their particular tastes; the charismatics don’t understand why we don’t get it; the pietists are always bemoaning other people’s lack of spirituality (especially their ministers) and the legalists are always looking for the next war in the church to fight."
Divisiveness in religion isn't, then, a trick promoted by an elite to prevent the wonderful egalitarian unity that might break out otherwise. Divisiveness comes from the ranks and works its way up. Well ... that's one way to look at it.
A shot of whiskey, a round of "fetch" with Angus, and we'll leave the future in the hands of a higher power ("however we choose to conceive of it" as they say at AA).
Labels:
Angus,
divisiveness,
Groundskeeper Willie,
religion,
Scotland,
The Simpsons
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Knowledge is warranted belief -- it is the body of belief that we build up because, while living in this world, we've developed good reasons for believing it. What we know, then, is what works -- and it is, necessarily, what has worked for us, each of us individually, as a first approximation. For my other blog, on the struggles for control in the corporate suites, see www.proxypartisans.blogspot.com.
